Through the €4 million project eEnviPer, the European Union invests in modernising local and regional environmental permit processes.
Environmental permits are a requirement for many economic activities across Europe, including intensive farming, power stations, waste treatment and manufacturing. However, the process can often be complicated or seem inaccessible to both those implementing the permitting process, and to those seeking to apply for permits.
eEnviPer provides an integrated web-based platform for the application, administration and consultation of environmental permits, making the environmental permitting process more transparent, more accessible and more efficient. Ultimately, eEnviPer helps to reduce the environmental impact of economic activities through the environmental permits process in a cost-effective manner.
Benefits
The eEnviPer platform aims to lower the effort involved in the environmental permits process for both public authorities and for operators: Information is more easily accessible, and defined workflows increase the speed of the process. After the initial investment to install and customise eEnviPer, the regular cost for the system is kept low as a result of the cloud-based architecture. Citizens benefit from the system through easier means to find information about current permits and to submit comments and contributions. As compared to existing, mostly paper-based permits processes, eEnviPer offers more benefits for the same price.
Interoperability
Governmental authorities need to combine a variety of databases and workflows to create suitable e-Government solutions for their purposes. eEnviPer uses a layered service-oriented architecture to take advantage of existing data sources and complementary environment-related permits systems.
Users
eEnviPer provides digital services for permitting authorities at different levels (local, regional and central). Authorities can then offer access so that:
- Enterprises can manage their own environmental permits application;
- Environmental engineers have access to relevant spatial data and applicable regulations to conduct the environmental impacts assessment; and
- Citizens can provide comments on ongoing application processes online.
In the first phase of the project, eEnviPer demonstrates this approach in five pilot communities across Europe: Puglia (Italy), Crete (Greece), Niğde (Turkey), Indjija (Serbia) and Krapina-Zagorje (Croatia).
For eEnviPer, the consortium partners have integrated existing governmental data sources and geographical information systems with Web 2.0 participation platforms and workflow solutions. The resulting single multi-purpose cloud platform is based on Service Oriented Architecture and provided as software as a service (SaaS). The project will be implemented over two years, with the final results expected in March 2014.
Policy Context
Fifteen years ago, the Aarhus Convention established that sustainable development can be achieved only through the involvement of all stakeholders. It linked government accountability with environmental protection and focused on interactions between the public and public authorities in a democratic context. This has led to a clear need for public participation and consultation during the environmental permitting procedures.
The idea of “e-environmental permits” was first discussed in the 1990s, and stressed the importance of IT security, subjective decision-making, negotiation and public participation in the process. Since then, a few notable e-government tools have been deployed in some countries. However, the European Commission admits that “e-Environment services, as a category of e-government services, are either still under-developed, or fragmented”. While there is a coordinated effort for the development and use of a Shared Environmental Information System (SEIS) – a collaborative initiative of the European Commission and the European Environment Agency (EEA) – to establish an integrated and shared EU-wide environmental information system together with EU Member States, environmental management and planning remains mostly paper-based.
At the same time, governments are today facing increasing demands to reduce overspending while citizens, enterprises and communities insist on top performance, efficiency and proper accountability.
Launching the 2011-2015 e-Government Action Plan for Europe, the European Commissioner for Digital Agenda Neelie Kroes expressed that the Action Plan aimed to ”help public authorities to use Information and Communication Technology (ICT) to offer better services at lower cost, while making life easier and better for citizens and businesses”. The Action Plan reflects the need for e-government services to move away from ‘silo’ government approaches towards a more integrated and collaborative approach in the service of good governance and single points of contact for citizens and businesses.
The benefits of e-government tools for environmental permits imply lowering the effort involved in the environmental permits process for both public authorities and for operators: information is more easily accessible, and defined workflows increase the speed of the process. Therefore, the use of ICT tools represents the simplification of the permitting procedures with the aim of overcoming bureaucratic burdens, performing the required tasks within the limited available resources (human and infrastructural), and ensuring transparency in the permitting process and thus increasing the engagement of citizens.
Description of target users and groups
The primary users of eEnviPer are regional or local authorities involved in the environmental permits process. Investors, environmental consultants and citizens can use the platform to submit, renew, or comment on environmental permit processes and to improve their communication with the respective authority.
In the five pilot countries alone, more than 200 regional or local authorities have been identified as potential users of eEnviPer. The eEnviPer survey on environmental permits processes and e-government in Europe carried out in November 2012 found out that one in three authorities processes a high volume of applications (up to 1,000) per year. This process is complex and time-consuming, especially when conducted using paper-based document management systems.
Public authorities benefit from streamlined workflows and a reduced bureaucratic burden through eEnviPer. They can also position themselves as modern and investment-friendly.
Environmental consultants are a crucial secondary target group as they provide the necessary expertise to investors and authorities to conduct a competent environmental permits process. They act to spread the potential reach of the solution to other customers and by extension, to help reach additional public authorities as advocates for its adoption. eEnviPer’s market assessment estimates that in total 4.000 environmental consulting firms and 21.000 individual environmental consultants offer environmental consultancy services specially targeted towards environmental permitting procedures in Europe.
Through eEnviPer, investors benefit from increased transparency and faster processing of their applications, ultimately leading to more economic development, and citizens benefit from easier access to information about developments in their area and more convenient participation from the comfort of their own homes.
Description of the way to implement the initiative
eEnviPer is testing its existing multi-purpose cloud platform between 2012 and 2014, with the final results expected in March 2014. In the first twelve months, eEnviPer has prepared the ground for the start of the pilot tests in the five pilots.
The European Union’s ICT Policy Support Programme is co-funding the pilot test of the eEnviPer platform in Puglia (Italy), Crete (Greece), Niğde (Turkey), Indjija (Serbia) and Krapina-Zagorje (Croatia). Each pilot project is accompanied by the responsible public authority and a local private sector partner.
The integration and customisation began with a thorough evaluation of the current situation in each pilot project:
- How are environmental permits currently administered?
- Which laws and registrations apply? Which agencies need to be involved in the process?
- Who are the people administering the process? Do they face constraints for internet access? Which training needs do they have?
On this foundation, the project defined a set of thirteen use cases and/or common procedures that the integrated software platform would need to deliver on. Pilots also modelled the workflows for their customised installation. At the same time, a detailed Pilot Implementation Plan determined the timelines, tasks and responsibilities during the test phase.
In February 2013, eEnviPer’s technical team presented the customised platforms for each pilot to the project partners. Subsequently, pilot partners localised and translated the software and started to train internal stakeholders in its use. In April 2013, pilot partners begin to test the platform using real-life cases with all stakeholders concerned.
Technology solution
The eEnviPer platform integrates existing governmental data sources on an as-need basis with one or multiple of the following modules:
- Geographic Information System. All permits are location-based and their evaluation requires data on the use of the surrounding environment, natural resources and protected areas and potential hazards.
- Knowledge Management System. To prepare the environmental impact assessment and to evaluate the application, environmental experts and authorities need to have easy access to relevant laws, academic studies and similar permits processes.
- Workflow Management System. These systems help the authority to move the application along the required steps in a smooth and fluid manner.
- Participation System. Finally, citizens will be able to review current applications online, access information in a secure environment and provide relevant comments.
The eEnviPer platform is developed using the following design principles:
- Service-oriented architecture. eEnviPer is structured in five layers that clearly separate data from functionality and display.
- Software as a Service. Initially, eEnviPer will be hosted at the DOTsoft data centre. Future installations can be hosted in local government data centres or by external providers.
- Interoperability. eEnviPer uses XML as standards-compliant markup language for its data inputs and outputs and interchanges information internally using XML web services (XML-RPC and SOAP).
- Security. eEnviPer uses identity management standards such as SAML 2 and WS-Federation to assert the identity of a user and control access. The platform ensures confidentiality and integrity of the information managed.
Mature Software Solution
eEnviPer is based on the software development framework DOTframework. It is already used in more than 20 small and medium enterprises and local governments in Greece.
DOTframework builds on open source technology, including:
- PHP as server-side programming language, supplemented with the smarty library for the creation of HTML templates.
- JavaScript as client-side scripting language, supplemented with the jQuery and Ext JS libraries to create interactive web applications.
- MySQL as powerful relational database system, other databases are supported too.
Customisation
eEnviper offers a fully customisable platform both for the user and the administrator. Extensive customisation and localisation options mean that each installation can:
- Integrate the design seamlessly with existing websites and online services.
- Provide rich user interfaces using powerful JavaScript libraries.
- Build basic to advanced custom content types.
- Support taxonomies and vocabularies.
- Integrate and customise third-party modules.
This flexibility allows eEnviPer to adapt to the specific requirements of each environmental permits process.
Technology choice: Mainly (or only) open standardsMain results, benefits and impacts
eEnviPer provides local, regional and national environmental permitting authorities with a service architecture to organise and assess environmental impact studies; share environmental information among authorities, enterprises and civil society; facilitate permitting and auditing procedures; handle large number of users / stakeholders; and reduce bureaucratic procedures and delays in the environmental permitting procedure.
eEnviPer’s interoperable architecture can be adapted to any other licensing procedure such as registration in regional, national or European registries and chambers that include assessments, audits and public information, thus delivering similar advantages in other areas of public life.
The eEnviPer platform aims to lower the effort involved in the environmental permits process for both public authorities and for operators: information is more easily accessible, and defined workflows increase the speed of the process. eEnviPer’s cloud services increases public officials’ productivity by organising and facilitating the environmental impact assessment procedure. Increased productivity results in saving public administrations’ time as well as their operational costs and will release public sector from additional management costs.
The eEnviPer platform also increases transparency by sharing environmental information which will improve the compliance of environmental legislation. This will be of great interest for consultants and engineers who want to use the available environmental information both in environmental studies as well as in other thematic areas such as spatial planning, financial and statistical analysis, etc.
Citizens benefit from the system through easier means to find information about current permits and to submit comments and contributions to ongoing environmental permit processes.
Finally, through the use of modern web technology, eEnviPer helps to reduce the environmental impact of economic activities through the environmental permits process in a cost-effective manner.
After the initial investment to install and customise eEnviPer, the regular cost of the system is kept low as a result of the cloud-based architecture.
Return on investment
Return on investment: Not applicable / Not availableTrack record of sharing
eEnviPer involves its Community of Practice, a wide network of experts interested in e-Government and environmental services, through email, Twitter and a LinkedIn group. To sign up, visit www.eEnviPer.eu.
eEnviPer also publishes widely on the subject of environmental permits and e-Government, including:
eEnviPer Profiles
Profiles showcase the work of the five pilot projects.
- #1 - Environmental Permits and the eEnviPer Pilot Projects
- #2 - Interviewing Indjija: Learning through collaboration
eEnviPer White Papers
White Papers describe the technical aspects of the eEnviPer platform.
- #1 - The Case for E-Government Tools for Environmental Permits
- #2 - Introducing the eEnviPer Architecture
Lessons learnt
Lesson 1: Environmental permits are ready for e-government
As an administrative process destined to reconcile environmental protection and economic development, environmental permits have often been seen as burdensome and bureaucratic. All participants involved in the process (civil servants, investors, civil society and experts) are seeing the benefits of web-based platforms in other areas of their work, and are yearning for e-government solutions applied to environmental permits, too.
Lesson 2: Process is more important than technology
The technology involved in eEnviPer is not new: software to manage workflows, participation and geographical information has been around for a long time. The real challenge for administration is often in better understanding the requirements of their own processes. After having worked with five different institutional settings, eEnviPer has built unrivalled expertise in modeling the required workflows and usecases for its clients.
Lesson 3: Regulation is a driver for change
Forward-looking municipalities and regions understand that administrative processes will increasingly need to be computerized. However, national legislation plays an important role in defining the principles and conditions under which this change should take place. Once national frameworks are in place, public authorities use them as a beacon for their own e-government initiatives.
Scope: Local (city or municipality), Regional (sub-national)