Mandatory and optional classes and properties

Anonymous (not verified)

Published on: 18/11/2014 Discussion Archived

Description

The specification of the CPSV-AP needs to define which classes and properties of the model are mandatory and which ones are optional to be compliant when describing a business event and public service.

Proposed solution

Class	Property	Mandatory/optional
Business Event		mandatory
Business Event	Identifier	mandatory
Business Event	Name	mandatory
Business Event	Description	mandatory
Business Event	Type	optional
Business Event	Language	optional
Business Event	Has Cost	optional
Public Service		mandatory
Public Service	Identifier	mandatory
Public Service	Description	mandatory
Public Service	Name	mandatory
Public Service	Is Grouped By	mandatory
Public Service	Type	optional
Public Service	Language	optional
Public Service	Has Channel	optional
Public Service	Processing Time	optional
Public Service	Sector	optional
Public Service	Keyword	optional
Public Service	Physically Available At	optional
Public Service	Requires	optional
Public Service	Has Input	optional
Public Service	Produces	optional
Public Service	Follows	optional
Public Service	Spatial, Temporal	optional
Public Service	Has Cost	optional
Input		mandatory
Input	Identifier	mandatory
Input	Name	mandatory
Input	Description	mandatory
Input	Type	optional
Input	Related Documentation	optional
Output		mandatory
Output	Identifier	mandatory
Output	Name	mandatory
Output	Description	mandatory
Output	Type	optional
Cost		optional
Cost	Identifier	mandatory
Cost	Value	mandatory
Cost	Currency	mandatory
Cost	Description	optional
Channel		optional
Channel	Identifier	mandatory
Channel	Is Owned By	optional
Period of Time		optional
Rule		optional
Rule	Identifier	mandatory
Rule	Description	mandatory
Rule	Name	mandatory
Rule	Language	optional
Rule	Implements	optional
Formal Framework		optional
Formal Framework	Identifier	mandatory
Formal Framework	Name	mandatory
Formal Framework	Description	optional
Formal Framework	Language	optional
Formal Framework	Status	optional
Formal Framework	Subject	optional
Formal Framework	Territorial Application	optional
Formal Framework	Type	optional
Formal Framework	Related	optional
Formal Framework	Has Creator	optional
Agent		optional
Agent	Identifier	mandatory
Agent	Name	mandatory
Agent	Type	optional
Agent	Plays Role	optional
Agent	Uses	optional
Agent	Has Address	optional
Formal Organisation		mandatory
Formal Organisation	Is Competent Authority Of	mandatory
Formal Organisation	Administrative Level	optional
Formal Organisation	Alternative Name	optional
Formal Organisation	Homepage	optional
Formal Organisation	Type	optional
Public Organisation		optional
Public Organisation	Public Organisation Type	optional
Person		optional
Legal Entity		optional
Location		optional
Location	Has Address	optional
Address		optional
Address	Full Address	mandatory
Address	Address ID	mandatory
Address	Address Area	optional
Address	Admin Unit L1	optional
Address	Admin Unit L2	optional
Address	Locator Designator	optional
Address	Locator Name	optional
Address	PO Box	optional
Address	Post Code	optional
Address	Post Name	optional
Address	Thoroughfare	optional

Component

Documentation

Comments

Anonymous (not verified) Tue, 18/11/2014 - 18:06

Questions received from Marco Aarts (The Netherlands):

For all new properties: which are mandatory?
Channel, cost, processing time, keyword, sector etc.: this varies for local administrations. PSC serves as a portal for referring to local administrations. Are these mandatory?

Anonymous (not verified) Fri, 19/12/2014 - 09:15

The WG suggested on making the “type” property of the Business Event and the Public Service classes mandatory.

This has been added in the new version of the spec.

Anonymous (not verified) Fri, 19/12/2014 - 09:41

Anonymous (not verified) Tue, 06/01/2015 - 12:16

Suggestion received from Patrocinio Nieto through the mailing list for making also the following classes/properties mandatory:

Public Service
- Has Channel
- Sector
- Has Input
- Follows
- Has Cost
Channel
- Identifier
Location
- Has Address
Address

Anonymous (not verified) Mon, 09/03/2015 - 09:23

Based on the mappings, we have revised the optional and mandatory properties and classes. This has been limited to the strict minimum. We refer to the UML model and the table included in annex of the release for the overview of which classes and properties are mandatory or optional.

philarcher (not verified) Wed, 30/03/2016 - 13:53

This table will be replaced by an updated version in the CPSV-AP Revision, work on which is about to start.

Mandatory and optional classes and properties

Component

Category

Comments